Criticism. Essay. Fiction. Science. Weather.
"They took it all, from that point just over there,
in 1979," Inge Brown said, lifting one hand from her
walking stick to point toward a barbed wire fence.
Beyond the fence, dense, tropical weeds and grass grew
thickly. "They said they were going to build a highway
through my land, and so the government took it under
eminent domain."
"Did they give you anything for your land?" I asked.
"Oh, no, don't be foolish," Inge replied, chuckling
ruefully. Her English still carries a hint of her
native Germany, though she moved here, to the
outskirts of Nairobi, Kenya, in 1933, to join her
British husband. Her husband passed away in the early
1970s, and Inge, now 96, has lived here alone ever
since. "I didn't know what I was going to do. We made
our living from our chickens, but when they took the
land, there wasn't enough space to get by on that kind
of work. Imagine! I had no savings, no way of making a
living. I had nothing. I was seventy years old and had
to start from scratch. And do you see any highway
here, twenty-five years later?"
I shook my head. The yard was surrounded by scrub
and, farther off, eucalyptus trees.
"I waited for them to build their highway, but no!
Instead I watched as those MPs built mansion after
mansion all around here," Inge explained, referring to
the members of parliament who no doubt became quite
wealthy from the transaction.
In the end, Inge converted two of the chicken coops
to guest cottages, which she rents out to the
itinerant aid workers who pass through the city in a
continual stream, earning just enough to pay for a
security guard and the groceries.
Though not a woman who would ever feel sorry for
herself, Inge loves to tell stories as she putters
about the property, checking on the flowers and the
few chickens who still peck around the yard. "I'll die
before I give up this little piece of land I have
left," she stated solemnly, and it was clear she meant
it.
Africa is not all AIDS and war, as it sometimes comes
across in newspaper coverage. An article last spring
in the
Washington Post sought to counteract that
doom-and-gloom image, explaining how the stock markets
in some African countries are booming; how Botswana's
national savings rate is second only to Singapore's;
how hard-working farmers navigate seemingly unpassable
roads, committed to get their crops to market.
I am thankful for coverage that
complicates the
pictures we often get of Africa, but when I mull
plopping my savings into the Ghanaian stock exchange,
I think of Inge Brown. Yes, there are a lot of hopeful
economic opportunities in Africa. But, in many cases,
they are not secure.
That sense of security -- that when you buy something,
as many of us have done quite a bit over this holiday
season, it's yours -- is easy to take for granted.
Though I don't mean to come across as an apologist for
unfettered capitalism, it is nice to be able to put
food on the table, send your kids to school, perhaps
even save a little for the future, and those things
all depend on a fair system of property rights. The
Peruvian economist Hernando De Soto's book
The Mystery
of Capital (2000), shows how the inability of the
world's poor to gain title to their assets means that
they are trapped in poverty. Never able to make their
resources fungible, it becomes nearly impossible to
make more out of what's there. All your energies go
into protecting the little that you have. At any
point, you could be evicted, like the tens of
thousands of residents of the outskirts of Harare,
Zimbabwe, whose homes the government razed over the
course of the past year, in an effort to get rid of
supporters of the opposition party.
The idea behind something like the Heifer Project is
that by giving someone a right to an animal, something
that can't be taken from them, they'll be able to make
that asset grow into something much larger. I've been
working with the
Rural Development Institute, an organization with a similar
goal. RDI focuses primarily on land rights and helping
countries develop systems of land ownership that are
fair, transparent, and accessible to all. Much of
their work has been in India, among the rural
landless. Once people gain access to even a tiny plot,
they are able to grow enough food for their family,
plus some to sell, and even plant a few teak trees,
which are a great investment. Though teak saplings can
be purchased for very little, when the fast-growing
trees mature in about ten years, they fetch hundreds
of dollars each. We're not talking fancy, expensive
solutions here, just making the rules a little bit
fairer.
While in Rwanda a few years ago, I met a man named
Pascal Gashumba. Pascal has lived near the top of a
hillside in the town of Byumba for nearly his whole
life, on a farm that has been in his family for
generations. Pascal lost some seventy-five members of
his extended family during the genocide. As we walked
around his farm, he could point, "Over there, that is
where they killed my mother"; "By those trees, my
brother was killed"; and on and on, seemingly
endlessly. Despite these memories, Pascal decided that
this was his home, and he would not be uprooted. After
spending a couple of years in a refugee camp in Congo
following the genocide, he moved back home to rebuild
his family house. He lived under a tarp in the yard
while he built the house, and when it was done, he
held a party, inviting all the hillside's inhabitants.
At the party, a few of his neighbors came forward,
leading a cow. Though all much poorer than Pascal,
they had pooled their resources to purchase this gift
to welcome him back, a symbolic offering in
recognition of the losses his family had endured, some
of them perpetrated by these very neighbors, or their
relatives. Pascal cites that cow as the gift that
enabled them all to begin anew.